Study of expert healthcare managers’ opinions on staffing issues in medical institutions providing primary healthcare services

Introduction. The staffing problem in healthcare remains relevant, especially within the system of primary healthcare services, which necessitates a comprehensive assessment of human resources and the development of measures to improve staffing in the primary healthcare sector.

Purpose. To examine the expert opinions of healthcare managers to identify the main directions for improving the staffing of medical institutions that provide primary healthcare services.

Materials and methods. The study utilized expert evaluation methods, as well as statistical and analytical approaches. The research materials include the results of a remote expert survey involving thirty experts — healthcare managers who met established selection criteria and competency requirements.

Results. Experts note the significant workload on medical personnel working within the primary healthcare care (PHC) system as one of the key issues related to human resources in primary healthcare. According to the experts, particular attention should be given to training specialists in educational institutions with a focus on the needs of practical healthcare. As the most significant measures of social support for medical workers, experts highlight the need for housing provision and financial compensation.

Key aspects for strengthening the human resource potential of rural healthcare include addressing housing issues for medical workers, developing infrastructure, and enhancing the material and technical base of medical institutions.

Research limitations. The research materials are limited to the results of individual expert surveys.

Conclusions. The use of expert evaluation methods in addressing staffing issues in primary healthcare is appropriate and allows assessing the problem based on the opinions of experienced experts, facilitating subsequent management decisions.

Compliance with ethical standards. The protocol for the sociological study was approved by the Ethics Committee for Sociological Research in Public Health at the Russian Research Institute of Health (conclusion No. 8/2024 dated May 8, 2024).

Contribution of the authors. All authors made an equal contribution to the search and analytical work and preparation of the article, read and approved the final version before publication.

Funding. The study had no sponsorship.

Conflict of interest. The authors declare the absence of any conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

Received: January 9, 2025 / Accepted: February 19, 2025 / Published: June 30, 2025

1. Karpova O.B., Zagoruychenko A.A. Current issues of staffing in healthcare in Russia and in the world. Zdravookhranenie Rossiiskoi Federatsii. 2022; 66(3): 181–7. https://doi.org/10.47470/0044-197X-2022-66-3-181-187 https://elibrary.ru/jodilu (in Russian)

2. Omelyanovskiy V.V., Bezdenezhnykh T.P., Alkhasov T.G., Lukyantseva D.V. International experience in health workforce planning. Meditsinskie tekhnologii. Otsenka i vybor. 2019; (3): 32–45. https://doi.org/10.31556/2219-0678.2019.37.3.032-045 https://elibrary.ru/qasehb (in Russian)

3. Sheyman I.M., Shevskiy V.I. Health labor policy: comparative analysis of russian and international developments. Voprosy gosudarstvennogo i munitsipal’nogo upravleniya. 2015; (1): 143–67. https://elibrary.ru/tmzdhx (in Russian)

4. Makarov S.V., Gaydarov G.M. The evaluation of efficiency of accreditation of graduates of medical universities as a measure supporting increase of numbers of physicians in primary health care section. Problemy sotsial’noi gigieny, zdravookhraneniya i istorii meditsiny. 2022; 30(2): 301–6. https://doi.org/10.32687/0869-866X-2022-30-2-301-306 https://elibrary.ru/gmxalc (in Russian)

5. Khodakova O.V., Senotrusova Yu.E., Deev I.A., Kobyakova O.S. Staffing of doctors in primary health care in Russia. Zdravookhranenie Rossiiskoi Federatsii. 2023; 67(6): 463–70. https://doi.org/10.47470/0044-197X-2023-67-6-463-470 https://elibrary.ru/ervopa (in Russian)

6. Rugol L.V., Kotlovsky M.Yu. Dynamics in staffing of medical organizations in the context of achieving the Federal project targets. Sotsial’nye aspekty zdorov’ya naseleniya. 2023; 69(1): 9. https://doi.org/10.21045/2071-5021-2023-69-1-9 (in Russian)

7. Karpova O.B., Zagoruychenko A.A. Regional features of the provision of medical personnel in Russia. Menedzher zdravookhraneniya. 2021; (8): 82–8. https://doi.org/10.21045/1811-0185-2021-8-82-88 https://elibrary.ru/zmuiab (in Russian)

8. Semenova T.V. Health care staff of Russia. Staff imbalance and its elimination in health care. Vestnik Roszdravnadzora. 2019; (4): 49–59. https://doi.org/10.35576/article_5d651dbc55e202.19015133 https://elibrary.ru/cyjakx (in Russian)

9. Men’shikova L.I., Son I.M., Kryakova M.Yu., Karakulina E.V., Vvedenskiy G.G., Kupeeva I.A., et al. Problems of organizing primary health care in conditions of personnel imbalance of district physicians and the ways of their solution (literature review). Sovremennye problemy zdravookhraneniya i meditsinskoi statistiki. 2023; (2): 771–803. https://doi.org/10.24412/2312-2935-2023-2-771-803 https://elibrary.ru/ccvmuo (in Russian)

10. Zadvornaya O.L. Problems and prospects of development of personnel support of the healthcare system in modern conditions. Sovremennye problemy zdravookhraneniya i meditsinskoi statistiki. 2022; (5): 528–45. https://doi.org/10.24412/2312-2935-2022-5-528-545 https://elibrary.ru/hqidtr (in Russian)

11. Sheyman I.M., Sazhina S.V. Human resource policies in the system of health provision: overcoming the shortage of physicians. Mir Rossii. Sotsiologiya. Etnologiya. 2018; 27(3): 130–53. https://doi.org/10.17323/1811-038X-2018-27-3-130-153 https://elibrary.ru/uscfwu (in Russian)

12. Karpov V.N., Khodakova O.V., Luchkina V.V., Shil’nikova N.F. The quality of medical care according to patient surveys. Kachestvo meditsinskoi pomoshchi. 2002; (3): 86–9. https://elibrary.ru/zcrykw (in Russian)

13. Bizin S.V. Characteristics of state personnel policy in healthcare: regional dimension. Ekonomika, predprinimatel’stvo i pravo. 2023; 13(10): 4169–92. https://doi.org/10.18334/epp.13.10.118954 https://elibrary.ru/tumbsm (in Russian)

14. Onishchenko K.N., Verna V.V., Onishchenko S.K. State personnel policy in the field of health care. Ekonomika ustoichivogo razvitiya. 2020; (1): 135–7. https://elibrary.ru/sillql (in Russian)

15. Kostin A.A., Ponomarenko B.T. The strategy of personnel policy as the basis of modernization of Russian healthcare. Gosudarstvennaya sluzhba. 2015; (4): 32–7. https://elibrary.ru/uerkhl (in Russian)

16. Pozdeeva T.V., Kochkurova E.A., Doshchannikova O.A., Noskova V.A., Kochkurov A.S. An integrated approach to the problem of staffing medical organizations in rural area in the region of Nizhny Novgorod. Profilakticheskaya meditsina. 2020; 23(5): 25–32. https://doi.org/10.17116/profmed20202305125 https://elibrary.ru/dcngxi (in Russian)

17. Tsytsorina I.A., Sharapov I.V., Ivaninskij O.I., Klevasov A.I. Expert estimations in management of regional public health services. Byulleten’ Sibirskogo otdeleniya Rossiiskoi akademii meditsinskikh nauk. 2011; 31(4): 112–7. https://elibrary.ru/oalzxv (in Russian)

18. Danelyan T.Ya. Formal methods of expert estimations. Ekonomika, statistika i informatika. Vestnik UMO. 2015; (1): 183–7. https://elibrary.ru/tqjpjl (in Russian)

19. Gorshkov M.K., Sheregi F.E. Applied Sociology. Methodology and Methods [Prikladnaya sotsiologiya. Metodologiya i metody]. Moscow; 2010. Available at: https://hse.ru/data/2013/09/06/1276838352/Prikl_Soc_full.pdf (in Russian)

20. Zagorskaya A.V., Lapidus A.A. Application of expert judgments methods in scientific research. Determination of the required number of experts. Stroitel’noe proizvodstvo. 2020; (3): 21–34. https://doi.org/10.54950/26585340_2020_3_21 https://elibrary.ru/tkkkco (in Russian)